Tiziano Treu Official Site logo Home Biografia Articoli Guida Lavoro Interviste Libri Notizie Foto & Video Contatti
Welfare

SUSTAINAIBLE SOCIAL SECURITY

SUSTAINAIBLE SOCIAL SECURITY

The questions posed to our discussion on sustainable social security touch on fundamental principles of the welfare systems. Sustainability is a multidimensional concept which requires to be analysed with an integrated approach by different disciplines.

1.  The multidimensional  concept  of sustainability 


The questions  posed to our discussion   on sustainable  social  security   touch on         fundamental  principles  of the  welfare systems. Sustainability   is a  multidimensional concept  which  requires   to be analysed with  an integrated  approach  by different  disciplines.


This  interdisciplinary exercise is not usual in  many field  of studies  and has  a    difficult testing ground in a highly complex  and controversial  area  like social  security. Even more  so because   this approach   cannot  be a merely  intellectual  objective,   but  must  be finalized  to promoting  policy  integration  among the different areas  of social  security and among  the  various components: the sources of  the  financing  the costs   of  organization and  of delivery,  the mechanism  of adjustement  between contributions and  benefits etc. Moreover such  an approach  is necessary to understand the two major aspects of sustainably: financial  and social. 


A further  dimension must  be considered, even if is not the focus  of this paper: namely political sustainability, i.e.  the possibility  of the national institutions to regulate and reform  their  social security  systems,  overcoming  the obstacles  and the resistance of (their) public opinions and of organized  interest  groups. The ageing  of population  is a major  factor  influencing  political decisions in this areas; particular the  choices  affecting social  security,  beginning  with pensions systems. 


The implications   of these  choices for the fundamental  principles  of our social  model  are particularly wideranging  when one  considers  not only  financial  but also  social substainability : because,  as I will  try to show, social  adequacy   implies  various  quantitative and qualitative  aspects of monetary  and service  provisions  of the social  security system. The very  concept of adequacy is multidimensional,  as indicated in the recent “Pension adequacy  report” (2018) of the European Commission. The Report  considers three  aspects of adequancy related to pensions,  but which can  apply with  variants   to other institutions  of social  protection. One is measured  by  the ability  of  pensions  and of welfare provisions to prevent   and mitigate  the risk of poverty. The second concerns their  capacity to replace  earned  income  while in work. The third is  measured in relation  to the  duration  of the period  in which  welfare benefits  are provided or needed.


Social  adequacy refers   not only to the amount  and duration   of income  replacement but also to the conditions  established  for the  effective exercise  of the right to benefits:  personal and family income requisites; age limits, organization and accessibility of services. 


Moreover  even the financial aspects of sustainability  are  not  simple  technical  and budgetary concepts. The various pensions  reforms which have  introduced  the defined contributions schemes with  the aim of guaranting  the  financial   equilibrium  of the system, have  to take into account  complex social  variables and adjust their functioning and variations to  the dynamic  of labor  markets, to  demographic trends, aging  and life  expectancy in particular, to  family compositions, and to the major economic indicators such of growth rate,  inflation, etc. 


In fact  most of these  factors are relevant, although  in different ways, both  for financial  and social  sustainability. This structural link confirms that  the two objects of sustainability are  interrelated, even  thought they have been  often pursued  separately by national legislators and  have  received  different  emphasis in the  various periods of time. 


  Different  reforms  in pension  and  unemployment benefits

I will analyse  some  aspects of substainability, as implemented in the  major  European countries. Specific  attention  will  be given to  two  major areas of social security,  namely old age  pensions and unemployment benefits.


Both  areas have  been recently object of reform in quite a few  countries  with  the aim of adjusting  the design  received from  tradition  to the  social and economic transformations,  including the economic  crisis,  which have  characterized recent years. 


On the basis of available  comparative  research  the paper  will consider  the  obiectives pursued by  the reforms in the two areas selected; the methods and techniques adopted; and the modifications which  have been necessary  to adapt the legislation to the  rapidly changing  economic and social scenarios. 


This analysis  will show that European  countries have  followed different reform itineraries  depending  on their  history  and on the political, social and economic context. We will see different applications of the principles  of sustainability  and a variable  impact on the social  and economic  performance of their system, but also  some (limited) convergence  towards common targets.


Diversity is present in other areas  of European labor  law and industrial relations. A major  institutional  reason of this diversity is that  according  to the  European  treaties both  fields fall within the  prerogatives  of  the national States. The original  separation  between national and European prerogatives  has remained unchallenged  throughout  our history and  has  greatly  limited the construction  of a social  Europe, leaving it basically to  the weak instruments of soft law. 


The old age pensions, both public and complementary,  have been the area  of social  security  most  frequently regulated by national legislators. They have reformed at different  times even important  features of their systems in order to respond to the changing economic and social environment. These repeated changes have been  at the center  of public  debate and  of political tensions, given the importance  of pensions in the system of  social protection and their  impact  on the life of people.


The pressures for reform stemmed from the  economic and social  transformations  which  have profoundly altered the basis  on which pension  systems were  built  in the last  century: population aging; technological  innovations  and global competitiveness,  accompanied with  flexible and mobile  patterns of work; lately slow economic growth culminated  in the crisis of 2008.


A great  body of comparative  research  has been  devoted to analyse  the reform  trajectories adopted in the various countries, showing many resistances  to change  the established patterns, but  also  the capacity of most countries to overcome the social and political  barriers to reform. These comparative analysis confirm the   existence  of a variety  of reform projects and outcomes. As in other  fields of social  policies the experiences of  European countries presents more diversities than convergence.


    Adjustement  of NDB  schemes  and systemic reforms (NDC)

Two major directions  and methods of reform can be detected  in our field. A group of countries  has abandoned the approach  of parametric (internal)  adjustments  of the  traditional defined benefits (NDB) schemes, which  had been  often  followed  in the past and  has approved a systemic reform that moved  from defined benefits to defined contributions  schemes  while maintaining  the unfunded character of the pension system; the so called  non financial  (or notional) defined contribution  schemes (NDC). The early  examples of Sveden  and Italy have  been fallowed by other European and non European countries: in  Europe, Latvia, Poland,  Norway,  in part  Greece.


A parallel direction of reform,  even more distant from  the traditional  pattern  spurred  by the Chilean reform of 1981 and promoted by World Bank, has been followed by those countries which have  moved  from NDB to fully Funded Defined Contribution schemes (FDC). 


The experience  of the countries  which  have  adopted NDC  systems has been   judged positively  by many  commentators. Some have  even  claimed  that  these  systems present the best characters for a universal public  pension scheme. In particular the one – to - one  relation between  individual  contributions and pensions  with  annuities based on life  expectancy  at retirement  is meant to provide  a transparent,  economically efficient and fair mechanism  for insuring  the population  against  the risk of outliving their resources,  yielding financial  stability  over time.  At the same  time the tight relationship  between contributions and  benefits is expected to offer better  incentives  for labor  supply  decisions,  including  for labor market participation  and for retirement age selection.  


The supporters  of these  reforms  have  underlined  a further advantage  of the NDC:  namely  that it takes  politics out  of pensions  thereby/favouring  clarity  and transparence. This  advantage  is due to the  fact that  the  functioning  of NDC relies on automatic  mechanisms of adjustment  inherent in the system. 


But  this  assumption  has not always materialized. Even  where - like in Sweden - the  schemes  have been  neatly designed and consistently applied, some  adjustment  have  proved necessary, in particular in order to cushion    temporary economic shocks and  to share  the systemic  longevity risk. These  interventions have   required  political  decisions and compromise. 


Moreover  in countries like Italy recurrent public  interventions have introduced  normative changes which  have altered  in various ways the  logic of the  contributory  system: e.g. the adoption  of fixed age threshold for retirement. Despite the potential  advantages  of NDC pensions,  the diffusion  of these  schemes has  been  limited  in recent years; and since  2015  the pace of reforms has slowed down  in  OECD  countries.


These two  approaches  have  been  applied differently  in the various  countries,  but  have  pursued  some  convergent goals which reflect common economic  and social  constraints.


The pressure of the internationalization and liberalization  of the economy,  combined  with  the  financial  requirements  imposed  by the  Maastricht  Treaty,  has contributed to bring to the  forefront since the major  reforms of the 90ies, the guarantee  of financial  sustainability  of public  pension. The (continued) increase  of the contribution  rates,  already  high in many  European countries did not appear a viable strategy.  


In order to respond  to the need  of financial  stability  some  alternative measures  have  been  adopted in a different  combination: a) raising the retirement  age, more or less rapidly, sometime (not often) combined with measures  of active aging directed to favor  the  prolongment  of work  participation; b) reducing or containing pension costs in various directions: e.g. harmonizing  downwards different  pension regimes, with  the aim of   reducing  those  granting benefits above  the average  via extra  yields; restricting  the conditions  and  controls of disability pensions; revising the criteria of pensions indexation; tightening  the link   between  contributions  and benefits  either  with  the adoption  of NDC systems; c)  (equivalent) corrections of the functioning of DB systems, in particular  shifting from  a full  salary to an average career salary formula  for  calculating the  amount of pensions. 



From  single to multipillar pension system

The application  of these measures has contributed  to reduce in various degree the  benefit generosity of the public  system. 


With the  declared aim  of  compensating for this benefit reduction many  European countries  have introduced  in the same period  supplementary  pension pillars. A second  pillar has been  usually  instituted and regulated by  collective  agreements, according  to occupations or economic  sectors;  and bilaterally  administrated. The diffusion  of these  supplementary  pensions  has been  promoted by the  legislators mainly through fiscal  incentives. In some  countries  it has been  made  compulsory or semi automatic via contracting  out mechanisms  or the like. Consequently  this form  of pension   scheme has acquired  an hybrid nature: characterized by private  origin  but subject to  public  regulations.


A third pillar  left to individual  decision   has also  been  promoted  or facilited with fiscal incentives.


 As a result of these reforms most European  countries already at the  turn of the century  had changed from the traditional  single pillar to a multipillar  pension system. As we shall see a well designed integration  among  these  pillars, particularly among the  second and  the first, can contribute to  guarantee not only sustainability but also adequacy to the pension system. 



  Implementation and corrections of pensions schemes 

The effective  pursuance  of  sustainability,  which in  principle is  ineherent  in the  NDC system,  depends mostly on the design of the scheme, and  on its implementation  in the  progress of time. In fact  even in well designed  systems  financial  sustainability  may require    corrections  or balancing  mechanism  for  introducing  the necessary  corrections.


An automatic adjustment  mechanism   implicit in the NDC  scheme  is the increase of  retirement  age  in line  with  life  expectancy, accompanied  with  a consequent reduction  in the annual  accrual  rate  of pension. But  even  NDC  schemes  are challenged by  heterogeneity in  longevity  among socio economic groups, an element  which  is widely  documented  among  OECD  countries.   


To prevent  possible  distorsion in individuals pensions,  DC schemes  may  apply  corrections   based  on individualized  life  expectancy    ether  at the  time  of annuitization  or during  the accumulation  phase. Gender  inequalities  in this respect can be  redressed  by applying  gender  specific  life  expectancies  at retirement.   The financial sustainability of NDC is challenged  by  economic and  demographic  shocks which  have  intensified  in recent  years and  which may influence  in particular the indicators  adopted  by the various  national schemes: the GDP  growth rate (as in Italy)  the per capita wage growth (as in Sweden), or the growth rate  of the contributions  wage  sum (Norvegy, Poland). Here too a balancing  mechanism  is necessary; either authomatic  such as has been  adopted  in Sweden  or decided through budgetary  corrections, in order to remedy the imprecisions of the  scheme‘s indexation.


The national  experiences  confirm the importance of these  elements. The Italian  legislator has approved  quite a few  variations of the  major reform of 1995 (Act 335).   


The long transition period aimed  at correcting some short comings of the original  design to the NDC scheme  decided  by the 1995 Act  has greatly reduced  the impact of the reform  in  containing   the financial burden  of pension  on the Italian  budget.  This  impact  has been  further  reduced  by the presence  of privileged costly pension systems; one linked  to the individual work seniority  irrespective of age and others organized  for specific sectors. 


Italy has still  the third highest  pension- related  revenue  as a  percentage of GDP (15.7%) in the OECD, while  the net replacement  rates  of current  pensions  are higher than the OECD average;  79,7% for a full career compared with 63% of OECD average.  And the effective  age of labor market exit  remains the fourth lowest in OECD. The adjustement of benefits  has been linked to period and not  cohort life expectancy. This choice  has introduced a distortion  in the calculation  of pension  benefits among generations the various cohorts. This distorsion  has been aggravated by  the fact that  


 In fact the Italian legislators  has intervened repeatedly  with  the aim of  guaranteeing  the financial  substanibility  of the system. It has raised the minimum age  for retirement, lately (in 2012) with an increase  of 5 years. This decision  is inconsistent  with  the  logic  of NDC  schemes  which  implies  not a fixed  age  of requirement but  a range  of possible  retirement  ages  within  which  the individual  may choose,  with the consequent variations  of the pension according  to principles  of actuarial  equivalence. 


Secondly Italy has introduced  in 2011  the application  pro quota  of the NDC scheme  to workers extempted by the 1995 reform. 



  The critical  dimension of pension adequacy

The two major lines of reforms implemented since the 90ies have pursued, with different methods and results, the primary objective of guaranteeing the financial sustainability of public pensions. Comparative research has shown that once sustainability gains were achieved, more or less completely, recognition grew in many countries that these reforms had to be accompanied with measures to safeguard pensions adequacy. In fact this dimension of public pensions has become increasingly critical because the reforms implemented has contributed to cause an already visible decline in the retirement income of future pensioners. In particular the stringent connection introduced between contributions and benefits has exposed the future pensions, specially for youngsters, to  the negative effects of the increased labor markets flexibility and of the growth of intermittent and precarious careers. 


In fact since 2015 many national reformers have focused on the various aspects of pensions adequacy. The European documents have renewed recommendations to the member States to ensure a high level of social protection, including pensions adequacy. 


Principle 15 of the European pillar of social rights stresses the right of workers and of self employed to a pension commensurate with contributions and to an adequate income during their old age. Here too the European scenario presents different measures adopted to ensure pensions adequacy and shows a variable capacity of member States to guarantee them in the  context of  economic instability and of flexible labor markets. 


The pensions adequacy report analyses a wide range of measures and suggests best practices to members States, following the soft technique of the open method of coordination (OMC), with the purpose of promoting mutual learning and convergence of social policies. 


These measures have a different impact on the two aspects of pension adequacy mentioned above. Some are meant to maintain the amount of pension closely related to income earned during working life. Others are mainly directed to sustain low pensions so as to guaranteeing minimum income for the beneficiaries; sometime are directed to combine the two objectives.


A majority  of European countries  allow people to work  while  receiving  an old age pension, even  within some  maximum   earning  threshold.


A general measure introduced by some countries to the same end  in addition to raising retirement age has been to facilitate longer work lives, sometime with monetary incentives (France) and often with policies of active aging.


Active aging has become a priority given the rapid aging of the population. The best practices have adopted a comprehensive approach to this issue, i.e. they touch on various aspects of working life, such as promoting learning opportunities during the entire life including the periods precedent to normal retirement age, or adapting the work place in order to favor the employment of elder people (flexible working times and part time, ergonomic improvements, career paths tailored to the abilities of the elders, promotion of heathy life styles).  


Some countries have used the leverage of indexation to improve the real value of pensions not only to protect pensions during economic downturns but also to take into account the increasing duration of retirement and to avoid pensions erosion. 


The European report quoted above underlines some improvements accomplished by public pensions systems, in particular the fact that retirement income is distributed more equally than work earned income. But, despite these improvements the same report lists a number of serious problems. 


The diffusion of old age poverty indicates that inequality among older people persists and that the risk of social exclusion increases with age. More than 20% of older women are at risk of poverty or of social exclusion. People in non standard and in self employment often face unfavorable conditions for accessing and accruing pensions. 



  Specific measures to improve  pensions adequacy

Specific measures are suggested, and have been adopted in some countries, aimed at guaranteing pension schemes more favorable than the standard systems to hazardous and arduous jobs which are exposed to short and often precarious working careers. 


Similar critical conditions are common on a larger scale to migrant workers who are typically confined to short and discontinuous careers. But the conditions of the migrants have not been so far considered by specific social measures, indeed not only in the field of pensions. Another critical aspect which is affecting the adequacy of pensions systems is the gap between women and men treatments. Comparative research confirms that this gap, while gradually narrowing, is persistent, because the cumulative effect of low wages and of multiple career gaps affecting women has been only partially compensated for by the pension schemes. On the contrary the structure on these schemes tends to multiply the inequalities present during the work life.


Reducing gender related pension inequality requires new policies in two areas. One: promoting full application of the measures supporting equal opportunities for women and men which are often written in the books but weakly implemented (work life balance, equal distribution of caring responsibilities, equal employment and career opportunities). Two, fully recognizing care-related work breaks for pension credits.


Innovative measures are needed also to face the increased mobility of workers among different types of activities. In many pension systems organized along sectoral lines this mobility may expose pensioners to dispersions and losses of  pensions credits and consequently of benefits. In order to counteract this negative impact some  States – including Italy - have recognized the possibility for workers to cumulate periods of work performed in different economic sectors and in different types of contract, without additional  or with reduced  costs. 



  Pensions  credits for career breaks

A similar risk of loss of pension benefits is caused by the periods of interruption of work during working life. A traditional measure aimed at  preventing  or reducing their risk has been to provide pension credits paid out of taxes for career breaks due to socially relevant reasons, either personal, (such as illness, work accidents, maternity and childcare, care for dependent family members), or linked to economic conditions, such as unemployment and temporary inactivity due to business slowdowns.


The types of career breaks recognized for pension credits, their duration and the amount of fiscal support are different in the European countries. But in many cases the limits posed to these credits make them insufficient to restore adequate levels of pensions. Indeed this approach has become inadequate to cope with the intermittent work patterns which have altered for an increasing number of people the continuity of employment well beyond the cases considered by the traditional measures. 


In particular these measures are insufficient to protect part timers which often are not adequately covered by pension schemes, because they are  considered a marginal group of workers mainly of women. This gap of protection has become quite serious since part timers are becoming a growing component of the workforce.


In fact the new structure of work patterns has posed a general threat to the traditional pension schemes. People in non standard works and in self employment, even in the countries which have included them in the general pension system, face conditions for accessing and accruing pension rights less favorable employed than those in standard open- ended full time jobs.


The increasing numbers of workers characterized by mixed traits of dependency and of independence are in an uncertain position with respect not only to pensions but also to other aspects of social security. Indeed they present a challenge to all the categories of labor law and of social protection, so serious that it requires a revision of major aspects of our discipline. 


An open issue is to verify which social rights must be extended to these new types of work, according to the principle of universality of basic rights and which other protections and benefits may be left to private institutions and to supplementary welfare schemes established either on an individual basis or collectively (if and when these workers will develop some kind of collective organization).



    Support to low  income  pensioners. Minimum pensions.

The insufficiency of the measures so far adopted to support pension rights of future pensioners has given more prominence to measures targeted at low income pensions and aimed at preventing the risk of poverty. In general it has contributed to introduce  redistributive  elements in public  pension schemes.


A measure approved by quite a few countries to this end has been to grant to low earners a replacement rate of pensions higher than that provided to average and high earners. But even the greatest “advantage”  provided in this respect (e.g. in the UK 50% point) does not compensate fully for the difference in work earning. Moreover the difference in net replacement rate is lower than in gross rate due to the impact of pension taxation. 


More specific measures in this respect are those which introduce some kind of minimum pension. The European documents mentioned above, confirm that the recourse to minimum income provisions for pensioners is vital, particularly in order to protect older women. Member states have set up a variety of systems aimed at responding to this need. 


A few legislations have provided universal flat rate benefits, usually based on residence and on age. Consequently all elders, including those with incomplete or atypical earning careers and those who have never worked in paid employment, qualify for this minimum income guarantees. The Netherlands is an exemplar case. This flat rate pension, rather generous in international comparison, has been important in preventing poverty in old age. This basic pension is supplemented by a general system of occupational pensions extended also to non standard workers.


A different solution adopted by some member States has been to include a guaranteed minimum amount of pension in the earnings -related pension system, usually at the condition to reach the pensionable age and to complete a certain number of years of contributions or of residence. This solution amounts to introducing a redistributive element in the commutative logic of NDC systems. The amount and the coverage of this minimum pension are variable among the States. 


The amount is often determined in a sum equal for all pensioners which is deemed to correspond to the basic personal and family needs, and is often accompanied by specific allowances (e.g. for housing). In other national systems the protection to low income pensioners is guaranteed by granting not a fixed basic pension but a sum linked to some elements of the individual work career, year of contributions, or to the age. This latter solution has been deemed more consistent with the NDC scheme, because it corrects its functioning in favor of old pensioners with fragile careers without depriving it of the principle  which is to make contributions pay. Moreover it carries a possible reduction of costs with respect to a general fixed basic pension, and  it can be adapted with fine tuning arrangements to different careers and personal conditions. 


In addition to basic minimum pensions most States provide a ultimate safety net for those elders unable to meet even the minimum contributory or residential requirements. 


The basic social benefits mentioned here are usually means -tested, according to conditions which are common to other benefits provided by social assistance schemes. 


These redistributive mechanisms inserted in the pension systems have acquired growing importance in the last years,  particularly after the crisis of 2008. In contrast to this trend some countries have cut benefits across the board including those for low earners. Others like Italy, Poland, Hungary, have tightened the link between contributions and benefits up to  the point of eliminating all or most elements of redistribution in their pension system. 


In these countries pensioners who do not reach the minimum requirements for pension rights under the NDC system are entitled only to a social allowance, which is means- tested and rather low, (in Italy it amounts to 5825 euro yearly). 


This result has been criticized as being inadequate to meet the needs of many low pensioner and because it deprives the pension system of its traditional redistributive elements, which are now more important than in the past.



   Supplementary pensions


A major strategy followed by many European countries in order to maintain an adequate income for pensioners has been to complement statutory pensions with supplementary retirement savings.

The forms of these supplementary pensions are quite different across Europe. 


In quite a few member States (UK, Netherlands, Switzerland, Denmark)  the adoption of a second pillar of pension has become mandatory or quasi mandatory in such a way to extend their coverage to the entire workforce. In other countries, including Italy,  supplementary pensions have been promoted by collective bargaining and supported by fiscal and other incentives, including cost effective access for different income groups. The European guidelines, already quoted, emphasize the potential contribution of these supplementary schemes, occupational but also personal, to reach adequate old age benefits within the national systems. The most important decisions  for   pension funds  administrators  concern investment strategy  and the subsequent asset allocation.


Recently some legislation has been approved with the aim of market diversification, of individualization of old age risks, of improvement of financial performance and of strengthening the rules and controls of these pension funds, in order  to bring confidence to the members and guarantees them against losses.


Nevertheless pension funds are exposed by their very nature to market fluctuations. The economic crisis of the last decade has highlighted their vulnerability to financial shocks and to economic downturns. In order to improve the safety of private pensions the EU has put in place specific directives finalized to strengthen the regulatory framework and  scheme designs. 


The diffusion of the various supplementary schemes, both in the form of defined contribution and of defined benefits, has contributed with their positive financial performance to improve the level of benefits for the pensioners involved in these schemes. 


However the benefits are not equally distributed across the different groups and generations of workers. The groups usually underrepresented in the funds (in those  countries  where  participation has remained voluntary) are those mostly in need of increasing the amount of their public pension, i.e. young employees, low wage earners and non standard workers, including part timers. The reasons which reduce the impact of private pensions schemes for these workers are similar to those which prevent public statutory schemes to guarantee adequate pensions to the same categories, namely intermittent and late work careers and scarce income capacity. Moreover their marginal position in the labor market and their scarce involvement in collective and trade unions activities, reduce their access to the informations concerning the opportunities offered by the second pillar of pensions and favor scarce trust in their effectiveness. 


The search of new formulas aimed at improving the functioning of these schemes has been stimulated, here as in other fields,  by the economic crisis of 2008, in particular with the view of finding a better combination between public and private forms of social security. An often quoted example of  virtuous combination of the two pillars is that of Sweden, where the first pillar of public pensions is supplemented by a public capitalized system of mandatory individual accounts which cooperates under a regulatory framework with the private sector, acting as investment manager. This solution utilizes private sector advantages without-depriving the system of its social character. 




    Unemployment benefits: insufficience of insurance - based systems 

Unemployment compensation schemes are the most relevant welfare program as regards income maintenance for unemployed people. 


In most European countries these schemes cover basically persons who have involuntarily lost their job. They provide income guarantees of a given amount, either fixed or most often related to previously earned wages and for a limited period of time. The European unemployment schemes present, like pensions and other welfare institutions, a great variety of features: different requisites for accessing the benefits, different duration and amount of guaranteed income. However most of these unemployment benefits share with  other forms of social security the common trait of being insurance based  and of being related more or less closely to previous work career and wages. Consequently these schemes, do not cover people who have never worked, and exclude in particular a growing number of youngsters like the NEET. Intermittent and workers with precarious career are penalized because they  often don’t meet the minimum requirements for access to the system. Moreover this type of insurance has been historically devised for dependent workers, leaving out self employed and independent contractors.


In some countries insurance- based benefits are accompanied, often with a phasing out period,  by social assistance schemes for those workers who have exhausted their rights under the insurance systems, in particular for   long term unemployed who have reached the maximum limit of insurance. 


The benefits of social assistance are usually means tested and not related to previous work earnings. The economic and social transformations of recent years have greatly influenced the functioning of insurance scheme for the same reasons which have affected other sectors of social security. In particular the economic crisis and the restrictive policies adopted by many countries and. by the European Union have increased the pressure to reduce the cost of this area of social security, at the same time in which unemployment was increasing all over Europe. On the other hand the diffusion of flexible and intermittent forms of work has reduced for a great number of workers the effective coverage of the insurance for the reasons just mentioned.


In response to these transformations many European member states have reformed the architecture of unemployment compensation. The impact of these reforms on the traditional systems has been often significant, even though it has raised less debates and controversies than those concerning the pension system. Indeed they have attracted scarce attention also by academic studies, even on the interaction of unemployment compensation systems with labor market dynamics which is decisive in determining the social and economic performance of these schemes.


According to the available comparative analysis the various national reforms share some common guidelines. A first common trend has been tightening  the links between work careers and the right to unemployment benefits. In particular the requirements for eligibility have been more closely connected with past work records, namely wages and paid contributions. Minimum requirements for access to benefits  have been raised often considerably, e.g. to two years in the UK, to one year in Belgium.


Work records have become increasingly relevant in determining the amount and the duration of income compensation. The former have been fixed in a declining quantity during the period of unemployment, following a widely adopted strategy of workfare. The right to receive the benefits has been subject to a variety of conditions. According to the same strategy of workfare benefit claimants are required to satisfy stringent work-related conditions. In particular they must prove their willingness to work by accepting job offers not necessarily correspondent to their previous employment or by participating in training activities aimed at increasing their employability. The failure to satisfy these conditions may result in benefits being withdrawn, reduced or not granted at all. 


A parallel trend has been followed by those reforms which have provided more precise targeting of benefits rights according to the characteristics of specific groups, e.g. students, family status (household size, age and number of children, disability).



  Measures to adapt unemployment benefits to flexible labor markets

A more promotional strategy has been followed by other countries (Belgium, the Netherlands) which have introduced financial incentives and training services aimed at favoring the transition of unemployed to other available jobs, or have allowed recipients to maintain some earned income without losing benefits rights. 


As mentioned already the recent growth of non  standard contracts of different kind has exposed an increasing number of workers to high employment discontinuity and consequently to low employment security. Indeed employment instability has been in the increase also for core workers hired under open-ended contracts, which are proving to be far from permanent and often of relatively short duration. But comparative research confirms that the risk of precariousness is much greater for most types of non standard, particularly intermittent and fixed term contracts, and that this high discontinuity is generally not offset by prompt transitions to new jobs. 


The negative effect of low employment security is often increased by the fact that recent labor market reforms have concentrated legal protections on core workers while introducing flexible rules for non standard workers: so called flexibility at the margin. 


According to the European guidelines on flexicurity the greater flexibility introduced in the regulation of employment contracts had to be compensated by reinforcing security of employment through various measures: income maintenance during unemployment and intensified services aimed at helping the unemployed in the search of new jobs. 


The guidelines  advocate  the participation of social  parties  to the design and implementation  of unemployment benefits and in general  to active  labor practices as a means to promote reinsertion  in the labor market and a better implementation of this strategy.     


The actual framing and implementation of the European flexicurity strategy have been quite uneven in the different member States. On the whole they have proved inadequate to maintain the promised balance between flexibility and security because the measures  aimed at reinforcing employment security on the labor market have been insufficient to compensate for the increased risks caused by more flexible regulations of labor contracts. The reduced employment opportunities during the crisis have increased the difficulty of assuring a prompt reinsertion in the labor market of displaced workers, even in the countries traditionally best equipped with active labor policies. On the other hand the reforms have reduced the duration and the amount of income compensation during the periods of unemployment which were being prolonged by the economic crisis. The combined effects of the two trends have penalized precisely those non standard workers mostly in need of protection and of security.


In response to these trends some countries have extended the coverage of unemployment benefits beyond the traditional categories of dependent workers by including in the insurance schemes some types of non standard workers. In the case of Italy where the traditional unemployment insurance covered a small percentage of the workforce, recent reforms (Act 22/2015) have raised this percentage to over 95%, which includes most of non standard workers, intermittent and economically dependent workers.


The Spanish legislator has extended the coverage to economically dependent workers  and self employed although these on a voluntary basis. But the tightening of the eligibility criteria for receiving the benefits introduced by the reforms has reduced even in these countries the practical impact of the extension of the coverage, because most workers are usually unable to meet  these criteria.


Indeed the trends mentioned above - restriction of access requirements and reduction of the duration of the insurance - have implied that even a great number of core workers have been losing the ordinary unemployment benefits based on their past work career and have been forced to pass from the insurance schemes to social assistance regimes. 


A more fundamental reform has been approved in countries like the UK where the unemployment schemes have changed from the role of replacing the lost earned income to the function of guaranteeing minimum benefits, subject to strict conditions of access for the claimants.  These new treatments, like most benefits due under social assistance regimes, are usually markedly lower than those provided by the traditional insurance systems. And they have not been increased to respond to the actual needs of the recipients. 


In a few countries the reduction of these benefits due to the strict requisites introduced by recent reforms (work related periods required for entitlements and conditions of activation) has made the benefits less attractive to claim, thus subtracting many contributors to the insurance system. Due  to these trends it has been noticed that  the very distinction between insurance and assistance schemes shows signs of blurring.


A different trend has been adopted in countries like Belgium where the objective of preventing early retirement has been pursues also by foreclosing the possibility of exit from the labor market through unemployment schemes or even by abolishing altogether a separate unemployment pension (Finland).



    DIFFICULT CHOICES FOR COMBINING FINANCIAL AND SOCIAL SUSTAINABILITY  

The relationship  between financial sustainability and social adequacy, contrary to the idea that they are two faces of the same coin, is not clear from a theoretical point of view and even less as a matter of policy.


The complex itineraries of social security reforms summarized here show that most European countries have faced difficult choices in reconciling financial and social sustainability.


The reforms approved by most member States particularly in the two last decades, have tried to adapt the systems received from their traditions in order to ensure that these systems could continue to be even in a long  term perspective  an important part of social protection of their citizens. This intense reform activity shows that welfare systems, contrary to common opinions, are not a static segment of the State apparatus, but are capable of reacting positively to the social and economic transformations.


The influence or the European Union on these reforms has been only indirect since the decision powers on labor and social security matters rests on national governments and parliaments. But the European guidelines, repeatedly adapted in the process of time, have contributed to promote reforms along common trends, particularly in the areas of pensions and of unemployment.


Recently the pressure  of the economic  crisis  and the  persistent  high level  of unemployment  have  called  for  a more direct  initiative of  the Europe Union in this policy  area, including  the adoption  of  a common unemployment insurance financed with European funds. The impact of the Emu has been significant in stressing the prior target of financial sustainability of social security, even though it has been claimed that this influence has not produced the much feared race to bottom. 


The capacity of the national reforms to guarantee the basic features of social protection has been challenged by the changes of the social and economic context on which social security depends. The pressures exerted on social budgets by the economic crisis and by the cost cutting  strategies adopted by many countries and promoted by the European institutions have reduced the resources available for many areas of social at the same time when  the needs and the expectations of social protection were increasing. 


A further factor has increased the difficulty of balancing financial and social sustainability of pensions, namely the increase in the life expectancy which has prolonged the time spent in retirement in a measure which has not been matched by raising the retirement age.


Thirdly the increased flexibility and volatility of the labor markets have supplanted the historic pattern of open- ended contracts and stable life- long employment on which most institutions of social security where based. Consequently they have challenged the insurance- based social security schemes adopted by many European countries.



14.    Strategies for promoting social adequacy


The national reforms have responded to these challenges with different strategies and with uneven results. On the whole they have achieved good results in guaranteeing the sustainability of social security institutions, both pensions and unemployment benefits. Adequacy outcomes have been less impressive in both areas. Indeed increased financial sustainability has been reached through reductions in present and even more in future adequacy, at the expenses of intergenerational equality. International research has given evidence that disparities in income distribution and poverty have markedly increased, particularly across generations. 


The established patterns of social security are exposed to so fundamental challenges that no minor adjustments is sufficient to make  them  perform their  function  in the new scenario. Innovative strategies responding to a new paradigm are needed.


A prerequisite for a successful innovation is to analyze in depth the changes in the dynamics of the labor markets with the view of shaping social security policies, consistent with these changes. 


A prior commitment of national economic policies is to develop robust employment strategies capable of better sustaining social security schemes. In turn the design of these schemes must be adapted  to more flexible labor markets, in particular with a view of supporting intermittent work careers and the frequent transitions that future workers will have to face. The connections between these two areas of policies need to be investigated by further economic research supported by empirical studies.  


Still we have enough evidence that the  reconciliation between financial sustainability and social adequacy is not possible unless we change the insurance- based structure of both pensions and unemployment benefits.


The European Commission itself has confirmed that the traditional design of pension schemes, (but the same is true for unemployment benefits), is well adapted to a world of standard employment patterns, but is less suitable for people with non standard careers. Applying strictly insurance-based systems systematically imperils the adequacy of social security for these groups.


In fact some reforms mentioned in our review have modified they social security schemes in the two areas precisely with the aim of correcting this bias.  The changes introduced so far have  been greatly influenced by the social and normative conditions of the national systems. In most cases have been introduced on a case by case basis.


This approach may be to some extent inevitable because both financial and social sustainability, even though well designed by the laws, are not fixed targets which can be reached automatically, but are moving horizons which need to  be continuously monitored in order to define the conditions and the procedures most fit for their attainment.


For this reason the  implementation of the reforms is decisive, here as in most other areas of social policies. And the procedures necessary to promote an effective application of the policy design cannot be left to ordinary administrative routines. On the contrary they require direct attention and control by policy makers, aimed at verifying the process of application and possibly at introducing the necessary corrections.


Moreover this political monitoring needs to be accompanied by the participation of the stakeholders, social actors and civic organizations, both to the process of implementation and to the adjustments of the original design.



15.    Guiding  principles: universalism  and solidarity 


Our previous analysis supported by comparative research, may suggest some general guidelines useful to promote a better balance between financial sustainability and social adequacy of social security schemes.


 A first guideline is to modify the architecture of social security organized on the basis  of different economic sectors and   of social groups  which is   still present in many countries, including Italy, towards a more universal coverage and harmonized treatments. The sectorial organization of social security schemes has brought about quite a few distortions and disparities of benefits among workers having similar needs, usually in favor of protected areas of beneficiaries, and to the detriment of newcomers. In most cases it has favored overlapping of institutions and of provisions with waste of public resources. 


Diffusing the principle of universalism in the various fields of social security can contribute to promote more equal and adequate treatments among the potential beneficiaries, and at the same time may be an antidote to the centrifugal trends which pervade and destabilize our societies.


Secondly a new balance has to be promoted between the commutative- individualistic principle which inspires the insurance- based schemes and the principle of solidarity, which is typical of most programs of social assistance and of the universal guarantees of social security.


This balance requires a new  combination of two functions of social security: that of providing total or partial replacement of personal income earned with work, and that of guaranteeing to all persons regardless of their work career, income and services adequate to their basic needs during the lifetime and in the old age (the two  may differ).


This combination has been pursued differently in the various countries because it reflects not only the national traditions but the basic conception of the role and place of work in society and in the constitutional organization-of the nation. 


Some European Constitutions, including the Italian, distinguish these two functions of social security by stating that all citizens unable to work and lacking the necessary resources for living have the right to be supported by social assistance, while the workers (of all types) have the right to be assured resources adequate to their life needs in case of old age, unemployment, work accidents, illness. 


The combination of these functions can be shaped in such a way as to avoid distortions and to take into account the new characters of the labor markets.



16.    Extending the coverage  of social  security and the  credits for career breaks


A first step in this direction is to extend the coverage of the various areas of social security to all types of work which have emerged in the new economy, according to the principle of universality, with the view of correcting the limitations and the inequalities of the sectorial insurance systems.


Secondly the design of pensions and of unemployment benefits may integrate the two principles mentioned above, commutative and solidaristic. While keeping a link with the years of work, both schemes could guarantee a flat rate of benefits, possibly combined with an amount of benefits proportional to past earnings.


Moreover the number of qualifying years for the benefits may be increased by including not only periods of actual work but the  all the  periods during which work is suspended for socially relevant reasons: in addition to those already considered in many social systems, (illness, maternity, work accidents, involuntary unemployment), all periods spent in performing care activities. 


The rationale of this  wide recognition of social security credits, as endorsed by some countries, is that these activities contribute to the wellness of society and consequently deserve to be credited for social security entitlements and to be supported by national budgets. A number of States have applied this rationale also to the growing number of part time workers, which so far  have received scarce or no social security benefits, by granting contributions paid out of taxes to the periods of part time unemployment.


This new design of social insurance has the positive effect of extending the coverage and of raising the amount of benefits to groups of workers mostly in need to be supported by public solidarity.


At the same time it can contribute to redress the balance between social insurance and social assistance, against the trend promoted by mainly conservative governments to reduce the share of insurance - based systems and to shift the emphasis on social assistance. The consequence of this neoliberal approach has been that assistance programs have remained the only form of social protection for a increasing number of workers: a protection which is  often of reduced amount due to the scarcity of resources and to the competition with other claimants (citizens and non citizens at risk of poverty).


The coverage and the adequacy of many programs of social assistance have been limited not only for the reasons just mentioned, but by the use of various types of means and income tests. The actual implementation of means testing, combined with high marginal taxes, has caused a increasing number of unclaimed benefits and of incomplete take up, which raises serious doubts on the functioning of many schemes of social assistance.


Furthermore, as Atkinson reminds us, receipts of means tested as opposed to unconditional benefits is stigmatizing.


 The inadequacy of existing social security schemes to meet the expectations of workers and of citizens has stimulated the search and practice of alternative ways to design these schemes. Indeed the growth of inequalities and of poverty among various sectors of the population, including workers, has posed a major challenge to the entire welfare system, even in the rich countries.



17.   Minimum income provisions  


In response to this challenge most European countries have introduced or reinforced various forms of minimum income directed to provide monetary support to poor workers and families, usually accompanied with personal assistance services to the beneficiaries, with a special emphasis on child care. 


In spite of common principles the types and levels of benefits granted by these measures and the conditions of access are quite variable and  have been adapted over time to respond to the needs of people in conditions or at risk of poverty. Poverty is defined according to criteria legally determined by the national systems. 


Usually the national systems of minimum income have maintained the approach common to most welfare measures, whereby (for people able to work) they are combined with labor and training policies aimed at activating the beneficiaries.  


The possibility to introduce measures of basic income unconditional, i.e. granted  regardless whether the beneficiaries work or are willing to work has been widely discussed in Europe and has been tested in practice with some limited experiments (Finland, Austria). But  so far the introduction on a general scale of basic unconditional income has not been decided. Indeed it has been deemed unfeasible not only for its costs but for objections of principle.  One: because disconnecting completely social security from the participation to the labor market would obscure or minimize the value of work and contradict the concept of social security as contributing to the activation of people; two: because it might contradict or reduce the prior commitment of public economic policy to the promotion of employment opportunities.


The actual costs of basic income depend not only on its coverage and level but also on its relations with other social security benefits. In many cases the forms of minimum income have been introduced in addition to existing measures of social assistance, with some specific targeting which has not been always sufficient to avoid overlapping of benefits. 


Some countries like the UK have introduced (and revised) a system of universal credit, which merges six existing benefits into one, with the declared aim of simplifying the access to the benefits, but also of better controlling their conditions and of reducing the overlapping of schemes. 


The introduction of a general form of unconditional basic income would dramatize the issue of coordination among social security measures and of financial sustainability. According to some estimates referred to the Austrian case, a non conditional basic income of 800 euro granted in addition to other social security benefits would result in raising the state social expenditures to 70%. An increase of such a magnitude of social security costs, which in many of our countries are already high, would hardly meet the capacity and the willingness of the active population to share the burden of such a measure. 


On the other hand granting basic income in substitution to all other welfare benefits, following a neoliberal approach to social security, would not contribute to promote equality among the beneficiaries and the citizens. On the contrary it might increase the gap between the poor and the rich because the former profit more relatively to the latter from the existing social security benefits (which perform redistributive functions).


The discussions and the controversies over this perspective are due to continue. They might be influenced by the impact of the digital revolution on the future of work. Whatever the dimension of the impact, certainly these technologies will represent a major challenge for the existing measures both of labor law and of social security. 


Policy makers and the social parties will be faced more drastically than in the past with two general alternatives:  find economic and labor strategies capable of promoting employment opportunities for people displaced by the new technologies, or pursue some redistribution of employment opportunities by reducing working time  (as the German metal workers have begun to do), and/ or by generalizing part- time work (even more than in the Dutch system). 


The impact of the digital revolution on the quantity of work might increase the pressure to experiment forms of basic income, on the assumption that no viable economic policies can be implemented to fight an irreversible decline of work. An assumption which we cannot take  for granted. 




18.    Common challenges to social security  and labor  policies 


The evolution of social security systems analyzed here confirms the need of further reforms directed to reconcile financial sustainability and social adequacy of the various kinds of benefits. This reconciliation is proving particularly difficult for the future generations in the area of pensions, which appear to be most exposed to the negative impact of restrictive social and economic policies and of  demographic  trends.


The pressure of new technologies and of the  increased global competition is threatening the adequacy not only  of social  security, but also of traditional employment policies.


 A significant evolution worth mentioning, because it is  somehow parallel to the changes of social security analyzed here, is the diffusion of minimum legal wages in many countries, lately Germany.


The pressure of the external factors just mentioned has deeply influenced the dynamics of the labor market, increasing the inequalities, exposing a growing number of workers to the risk of unemployment, and often obliging them to accept working conditions and salaries much below the average standards. Legally defined minimum wages have been usually introduced in order to compensate for the reduced capacity of collective agreements to perform their traditional function of wage regulators, particularly for the growing number of atypical workers and for regular workers of low skills and qualification.


These minimum salaries can be  broadly grouped into two categories, universal  regimes which define a general  wage floor  for all employed workers, and sectoral regimes which set a minimum wage  for specific branches and/or occupational groups. 


Usually they perform the function not of fixing the wage  correspondent to the specific job hold by the individual, but of guaranteeing an income sufficient to meet the basic needs of the worker and of its family. This function of minimum wage which is explicitly mentioned in the Italian constitution (art 36), goes beyond the concept of a strict counterpart of the work dove and embodies a principle of adequacy. In this respect the function is similar to that of social security institutions.


This diffusion of minimum wages and the evolution of their functions are significant indicators of the need to coordinate labor market policies with social security measures.


The European guidelines on flexicurity which have been the most significant benchmark for national labor market policies are an example of this kind of coordination. According to the guidelines labor regulations introducing more flexibility in employment contracts need to be accompanied with active labor and training policies and economic supports aimed at providing security to the workers in the transitional labor markets.


The fragmentation of work patterns requires  that labor policies adopt new instruments capable of  guaranteeing employment continuity in the variation of job positions. On the other hand welfare policies will be challenged to sustain  employment  transitions with  new more focused measures: in particular  services and  income support directed to promote the reemployment  of unemployed workers and employment  of inactive   persons; paid leaves for periods   of   inactivity  due to  personal  reasons (not only parenthood, illness, work accidents, but also professional upgrading); personal services aimed at facilitating work life balance and professional  and territorial mobility.


 In this perspective  welfare  measures  need to be  better integrated  with  labor policies  with the aim  of helping them in the difficult task of fighting  precariousness and promoting quality employment. Indeed the institutions of  social security  should perform  a major role  for the future  of labor relations, because they will be decisive in correcting the deficiencies and  failures of transitional labor markets. 


18.    Coordination of different  policies  and common levels of adequacy 


The forms of this coordination must be further investigated in order to adjust social security institutions to the changing dynamic of the labor markets and to the new  forms  of work. In performing these  new functions the institutions of social  security will still (or even more) be required  to maintain a balance between the two guiding principles of sustainability and adequacy. 


The meaning of adequacy has to be examined in relation to the various areas so as to reflect the different functions of the benefits, in particular to determine the level of income to be guaranteed to the beneficiaries.


The various forms of social assistance, in so far as they perform the function to satisfy fundamental needs of workers (or possibly of citizens) with resources provided through the solidarity of the national community and defined in the public budgets, should be designed  in such a way to provide a similar level of benefits, even though with variable forms of income guarantee and of services.


Some national experiences show convergent trends in this direction. In particular the common objective  should be to provide similar basic treatments in the amount of minimum income, in favor of workers who are unemployed beyond the maximum terms provided for insurance- based benefits, and in case of minimum social pensions. These income guarantees may  be accompanied by special allowances and by personal care and health services according to the specific conditions and needs of the beneficiaries.


Minimum wages are usually fixed at a level higher than minimum income which is justified by their multiple function. Even though they perform not a purely commutative but a social function, they correspond to a specific work activity which deserves to be rewarded.



Vuoi saperene di più?

Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!

Privacy: