Tiziano Treu Official Site logo Home Biografia Articoli Guida Lavoro Interviste Libri Notizie Foto & Video Contatti
Riforme e tendenze generali

SUSTAINABILITY, HUMAN RIGHTS AND BUSINESS

Verso un Futuro Sostenibile: Sfide, Politiche e Strumenti per il Lavoro

Sostenibilità e diritti umani si intrecciano nel lavoro: rischi, opportunità e ruolo chiave delle imprese per il futuro.

1. Evolution of the Theory and Practice of Social Rights – Social Rights and Human Rights

The theory and practice of social rights, throughout their long history, have undergone continuous evolutions linked to transformations in both the national and international context.

“They depend, as J. Somavia writes in the introduction to a recent history of the ILO, ‘on the major global events: economic crises, social conflicts, wars, and in recent years, global policies that run counter to ILO values” .

Despite the recurring challenges to the affirmation of these rights, both their number and content have grown over the years, as witnessed by the evolution of the ILO and the regional and national institutions that have adopted them .

To the initial civil and political rights were added economic, social, and cultural rights, or second-generation rights, covering labor, health, education, and more recently, the right to safety at work; then came third- and fourth-generation human rights, which include the self-determination of peoples, the right to peace, and the right to development in a healthy environment.

At the 2024 Venice International Seminar there was an extensive debate on the possible qualification of social and labor rights as human rights. A trend was noted in international sources—from ILO standards, the European Charter of Fundamental Rights, to recent European directives, particularly the so-called Due Diligence directive—to expand the number and types of social rights to be classified as human rights.

The debate clarified that the issue is not merely terminological. While the term “labor standards” used by the ILO alludes to a technical issue, limited to narrow labor matters (wages, hours, etc.), the designation “human rights” signals that something of greater human and moral significance is at stake—that is, a right owed to the person as such, one that refers to universal values even though it assumes specific features when the person is at work.

Relying on the universal nature of these rights, the jurisprudence of International Human Rights Courts, starting with the European one, has been able to apply them to remedy situations in need of protection that are not recognized by labor law regulations: extending them to non-salaried workers, non-citizens, and especially to vast areas of the world where labor law has not yet reached .


2. Instruments for the Effectiveness of Rights

The developments that have accompanied the spread of social and human rights testify to the difficulty of ensuring their effective implementation in various international contexts, including those of advanced countries. This difficulty is due not only to practical obstacles but also to recurrent attempts to diminish both their normative value and their political justification and practicability.

Yet, the pursuit of effectiveness is paramount if we do not want these rights to remain empty promises. It must be supported by the conviction that ensuring the effective observance of social and human rights is an essential condition for human and sustainable development.

In practice, this pursuit has yielded mixed results depending on the periods and countries involved, despite the commitment of labor institutions and social partners who have been engaged in support and monitoring activities.

The implementation of the principles set forth in the international rights charters is entrusted to the mechanisms of these institutions—the judiciary and labor inspectorates—augmented by additional procedural tools ranging from transparent and widespread dissemination of information on rights to the simplification of procedures for accessing public and associative services, as well as counseling and legal support for the exercise of these rights.

Recently, it has been proposed to establish that compliance with the rights provided by the Social Pillar be a general condition for accessing European funds. This new type of “social conditionality” 5could be a particularly effective tool at the Union’s disposal to stimulate the actual respect of social (and environmental) standards.

The importance of these instruments is underscored by the high percentage of legally recognized social benefits that remain unclaimed, especially those more difficult to access by vulnerable groups.

It should also be noted that the recognition of social rights by the European Union is supported not only by the procedures mentioned above but also by action plans equipped with funds and specific apparatus designed to support their implementation in various national contexts.

The Action Plan for implementing the European Pillar of Social Rights is indicative of this intervention method aimed at transforming the 20 Pillar principles into concrete actions for the benefit of European citizens, with clearly established deadlines and objectives to be met by 2030.

This approach emphasizes the connection of the affirmation of rights not only with legislative and contractual regulations that specify their legal content, but also with the economic and social policies that must define their framework—ultimately determining the effectiveness of these rights and principles.

This method of programmed action at the European level, to be implemented in the Member States, has given the Social Pillar an effectiveness beyond the modest expectations that had been predicted for it, like for other soft law interventions by the European Union in the social field.

For this reason, it is entirely appropriate that the presentation at the Venice seminar focuses on “rights in action,” an emphasis on which modern Italian labor doctrine has been urged to concentrate from its very origins.

In the same vein, but with greater difficulty, the ILO has engaged not only with its (weak) legal instruments but also with concrete on-the-ground interventions to support the effectiveness of these instruments in different global scenarios.

It is equally significant that the ILO has attached great importance to the fight against “informal labor” in its various forms of illegality and exploitation. This phenomenon affects the majority of the world’s workers, and it is not overcome even in developed areas and European countries, as evidenced by the resources allocated to counter it in various national recovery and resilience plans, including our own .




3. Globalization and the Internationalization of Human Rights

The rise of market globalization, which has impacted labor markets in different ways, has posed an entirely new challenge to the effectiveness of rights, requiring approaches suited to the supranational dimension.

The search for instruments capable of ensuring the rights of workers beyond the confines of national jurisdictions is only just beginning. It must contend, with the speed of economic and labor transformations accelerated by the powerful vehicle of digital technologies.

The social clauses in international treaties, which have been painstakingly disseminated and evolved over the years, show numerous operational limitations, now exacerbated by recent geopolitical tensions that are disrupting the already precarious order of the multilateral trading system .

A different mechanism, introduced by recent national regulations and European directives (the French law of March 27, 2017, on corporate due diligence and the EU Due Diligence Directive 2024/1760), has leveraged large corporate groups and their value chains to commit them to ensuring respect for the fundamental rights of workers and the safeguarding of the environment .

The assessment of the impact of these regulations is in its early stages. Only experimentation will reveal how the novelty of the instrument—namely, the internal links within corporate groups, used as a substitute for traditional relationships between States and public institutions—will affect the implementation of rights, particularly but not exclusively at the supranational level.

This is an issue that deserves further exploration, starting with this very seminar. It is one of the most critical aspects of the relationship between human rights and businesses.

This is a topic that labor law has long neglected to analyze—in fact, it has often ignored it altogether. I am convinced, not alone, that the traditional focus of our field and industrial relations on issues of distribution and labor protection cannot justify overlooking the problems of economic growth, its conditions, and the choices of its main actors, the enterprises.


Leggi l'Articolo in PDF


Vuoi saperene di più?

Compila il seguente form. Ti risponderemo il prima possibile!

Privacy: